Mechanical trustworthiness
Posted: Sat Mar 25, 2017 9:09 am
I sometimes have second thoughts about carrying my P320. No safety. Anything that engages the trigger fires the gun, and I don't believe in empty chambers.
My holster isn't the fanciest (Alien Gear), but I've carefully confirmed nothing can touch the trigger. It's also important to make sure that nothing can drag against the edge of the trigger, even if it could never apply enough force through friction to discharge the firearm. That safety check led me to acknowledge something I've always thought but never really expressed.
Witness the sheetrock oopsies brought about by a negligent discharge from a P320, documented on sigtalk.com. I don't think anyone on that forum nailed the root cause of the sheetrock and hearing damage.
The poster said he had played with the free wiggle in his trigger the day before. The morning of his ND he wiggled the trigger 4 or 5 times, and, golly, it went off.
Therein lies what I've begun to think of as a corollary to Cooper's Rule about keeping one's idiot finger off the trigger until ready to fire.
On single action guns, once any weight has rested on the trigger it can't be trusted.
The P320 is a single action pistol. For a long time, Sig's web site said the P320 didn't fully cock its striker on return to battery but that's not true. The striker is at full cock unless it's been dry fired. That nice trigger feel is because you're not hauling back a spring, just clearing a firing pin block and releasing the sear.
If the sear is partially disengaged I don't think it will reset itself. Pull the trigger a little bit less than what makes a bang and now the sear stays partially released. If a gun is dropped, its sear may well bounce into an insecure state, ready to fire at the point the trigger moves enough to unblock the firing pin, long before the shooter expects a really loud noise, and without regard to whether the gun is considered drop safe.
Pull the trigger on a cocked and locked 1911 and the safety will keep it from discharging - but did the sear move a thousandth of an inch?
There's no way a Monday morning quarterback can know about the P320 ND. The information in the Sigtalk forum is limited. My best guess is the trigger wiggling the day before partially unseated the sear, leaving it ready to release with the slightest jiggle. Unfortunately, that last jiggle must have coincided with the firing pin block being clear from some rearward movement of the trigger.
So, my advice, if a single action gun is mishandled - dropped, or something or somebody stupidly moves the trigger - don't trust the gun. Do what you need to restore the gun to full cock. In the case of the P320, I think drawing the slide back enough to let the striker run full forward and lift off of the sear is probably sufficient. For a cocked and locked 1911, the safety can stay on while you pull the hammer back and then gently let it come forward to rest on the sear.
Probably not a bad idea to holster a firearm the same way you'd give a rattlesnake an enema, too. Smoothly, gently, and with the realization a little ham-handedness might make it strike.
Stay safe.
My holster isn't the fanciest (Alien Gear), but I've carefully confirmed nothing can touch the trigger. It's also important to make sure that nothing can drag against the edge of the trigger, even if it could never apply enough force through friction to discharge the firearm. That safety check led me to acknowledge something I've always thought but never really expressed.
Witness the sheetrock oopsies brought about by a negligent discharge from a P320, documented on sigtalk.com. I don't think anyone on that forum nailed the root cause of the sheetrock and hearing damage.
The poster said he had played with the free wiggle in his trigger the day before. The morning of his ND he wiggled the trigger 4 or 5 times, and, golly, it went off.
Therein lies what I've begun to think of as a corollary to Cooper's Rule about keeping one's idiot finger off the trigger until ready to fire.
On single action guns, once any weight has rested on the trigger it can't be trusted.
The P320 is a single action pistol. For a long time, Sig's web site said the P320 didn't fully cock its striker on return to battery but that's not true. The striker is at full cock unless it's been dry fired. That nice trigger feel is because you're not hauling back a spring, just clearing a firing pin block and releasing the sear.
If the sear is partially disengaged I don't think it will reset itself. Pull the trigger a little bit less than what makes a bang and now the sear stays partially released. If a gun is dropped, its sear may well bounce into an insecure state, ready to fire at the point the trigger moves enough to unblock the firing pin, long before the shooter expects a really loud noise, and without regard to whether the gun is considered drop safe.
Pull the trigger on a cocked and locked 1911 and the safety will keep it from discharging - but did the sear move a thousandth of an inch?
There's no way a Monday morning quarterback can know about the P320 ND. The information in the Sigtalk forum is limited. My best guess is the trigger wiggling the day before partially unseated the sear, leaving it ready to release with the slightest jiggle. Unfortunately, that last jiggle must have coincided with the firing pin block being clear from some rearward movement of the trigger.
So, my advice, if a single action gun is mishandled - dropped, or something or somebody stupidly moves the trigger - don't trust the gun. Do what you need to restore the gun to full cock. In the case of the P320, I think drawing the slide back enough to let the striker run full forward and lift off of the sear is probably sufficient. For a cocked and locked 1911, the safety can stay on while you pull the hammer back and then gently let it come forward to rest on the sear.
Probably not a bad idea to holster a firearm the same way you'd give a rattlesnake an enema, too. Smoothly, gently, and with the realization a little ham-handedness might make it strike.
Stay safe.