Re: Which .22LR?
Posted: Fri Nov 21, 2008 10:36 pm
I thought it odd that the Marlin 60 wasn't on your list from the beginning. I don't personally own one but my best friend does. I have two 10/22's and would never recommend one, which puts me into a distinct minority.
I have a beautiful Deluxe 10/22 from the '80's and I have one that I bought for $139 and added a target barrel and Hogue overmolded stock.
If you want to spend money accessorizing a .22, then go for the 10/22. But if you want an accurate, reliable, trouble tree .22 then buy the Marlin 60.
And I MUCH prefer the tube magazine over detachables. I've probably bought 25-30 factory 10/22 magazines at from $10-$16 each and if they work right, they don't work right for very long. That statement will flood this thread with posts from people who swear by 10/22 mags and never had a problem with one. Try doing some reading at http://www.rimfirecentral.com" onclick="window.open(this.href);return false;. You can download pages of instructions on how to disassemble, clean, and most importantly, how to retension a factory 10/22 magazine so that it will actually work.
With regards to the 597, the first issue mag was a plastic one which didn't work. The factory replaced those with a cast aluminum or some other cheap metal that after a year in my safe looked like it had spent that year submerged in salt water. When the factory replaced these, I have had no other problems. Still, the 597 never felt like a real gun.
I would get the Marlin 60 with a wood stock. If you want to go all out, it is offered in stainless with a laminated wood stock that is very nice.
I have a beautiful Deluxe 10/22 from the '80's and I have one that I bought for $139 and added a target barrel and Hogue overmolded stock.
If you want to spend money accessorizing a .22, then go for the 10/22. But if you want an accurate, reliable, trouble tree .22 then buy the Marlin 60.
And I MUCH prefer the tube magazine over detachables. I've probably bought 25-30 factory 10/22 magazines at from $10-$16 each and if they work right, they don't work right for very long. That statement will flood this thread with posts from people who swear by 10/22 mags and never had a problem with one. Try doing some reading at http://www.rimfirecentral.com" onclick="window.open(this.href);return false;. You can download pages of instructions on how to disassemble, clean, and most importantly, how to retension a factory 10/22 magazine so that it will actually work.
With regards to the 597, the first issue mag was a plastic one which didn't work. The factory replaced those with a cast aluminum or some other cheap metal that after a year in my safe looked like it had spent that year submerged in salt water. When the factory replaced these, I have had no other problems. Still, the 597 never felt like a real gun.
I would get the Marlin 60 with a wood stock. If you want to go all out, it is offered in stainless with a laminated wood stock that is very nice.