TexasCHLforum.com

Monker10 wrote:Also the argument they make by saying they don't want these weapons to go to the wrong hands is moot. I have never heard of a criminal committing a crime using a WWII antique.

Nor have I. But that may be just because criminals have no taste in weapons. An M1 is one heck of a weapon, despite being an antique. A Springfield M1A is very high on my wish list. I've considered an M1 from the CMP. I probably won't do much hunting with it.
The M1 Carbine might appeal to more criminals, being smaller and lighter. Problem is that ammo is sorta hard to come by for those. (Not completely unavailable, but you have to scrounge a bit for it, I think.)
You are right. Not many crimes are committed with "assault rifles," so it's ulikely they're going to lug a real battle rifle down to the 7-11 to clean out the cash register.

I think the US government needs to buy them and sell them through the CMP, after all we just recently ran out of them.

The only thing the political class understands (and reacts to) is political pressure. Let's hope the NRA can apply that pressure for us.

Monker10 wrote:Since these rifles where given to South Korea then it's already considered a monetary loss on the US end. If they are allowed to sell these rifles back to US citizens it would greatly help our ally and if there is a import tax imposed the the US then they can at least recover a portion of their previous loss. It's a much better alternative then just destroying them. This administration is always talking about how important it is to decrease the deficit. Well this was their perfect opportunity to make a dent. Also the argument they make by saying they don't want these weapons to go to the wrong hands is moot. I have never heard of a criminal committing a crime using a WWII antique. It's just the usual fear mongering anti gun propaganda.

OUTSTANDING POINT!!!

The knee-jerk reaction is that money has no real bearing on anything. If it is gun-related it is bad, regardless of the potential revenue-generating, deficit-fighting impact that the sale of these guns in the US might represent.
Besides, how many folks on this board really think that the current administration (and apparently our own State Department) have any concerns about balancing the Federal budget?

Well, heck. They are bent on destroying everything else about this country so why not?

Small point.. 'dispose' != destroy.

I can 'dispose' of my estate, via selling it. The OP came off a bit hyperbolic.

Ashlar wrote:Small point.. 'dispose' != destroy.

so instead of disposing them by sale to Americans, they can dispose of them by sale to Mexican drug cartels and gangs.

South Korea now owns them, not the US Gov't.

Chicken Little'ing doesn't help.

Ashlar wrote:South Korea now owns them, not the US Gov't.

Yes and they'll find another buyer if the ObamaNation blocks the planned sale to decent people.

longhorn_92 wrote:Makes me want to buy an M1 Garand and M1 Carbine... just for spite!

The M1 Carbine is a great little rifle. It's easy to clean and maintain, not that it needs much maintenance. It’s a heck of a lot more dependable than any AR I’ve ever handled. It’s not much for stopping power compared to the .223 but when I was a kid, I took many deer with the one my dad carried in Korea. It has similar ballistic characteristics as the .357 magnum.

Mine has never jammed once, not ever. No matter how dry I let it get it still runs like a champ. I certainly can’t say that about my ARs.

The only hiccup these days are that ammo is scarce. By scarce I mean that there is none being sold as surplus any more and the stuff we purchase is very expensive compared to other calibers.

I’ll certainly get a couple more myself when they come online.

Only problem I've ever had with my M1 carbines is spitting out unfired rounds, and having to tweak the feed lips on every magazine.

TDDude wrote: The only hiccup these days are that ammo is scarce. By scarce I mean that there is none being sold as surplus any more and the stuff we purchase is very expensive compared to other calibers.

I get mine at Cabela's. Prvi Partisan is less than $20/50, and if you catch a sale, less than that.

Ashlar wrote:Only problem I've ever had with my M1 carbines is spitting out unfired rounds, and having to tweak the feed lips on every magazine.

You must have had defective mags. I've never experienced that.

The original short mag however developed a weak mag spring but it was at least 50 years old when it happened. It simply wouldn't feed the very last round in the mag. My original long mag works just fine.

TDDude wrote:

Ashlar wrote:Only problem I've ever had with my M1 carbines is spitting out unfired rounds, and having to tweak the feed lips on every magazine.

You must have had defective mags. I've never experienced that.

The original short mag however developed a weak mag spring but it was at least 50 years old when it happened. It simply wouldn't feed the very last round in the mag. My original long mag works just fine.

Very old long mags were the worst- the feed lips relax, and you end up with an unfired round (or five) among all your fired brass.