TexasCHLforum.com

hirundo82 wrote:

RPB wrote:I'm wondering since it doesn't "look like" a typical pistol, if it will win an AOW award from BATFE like the old "cane gun/umbrella gun" etc.

I would have thought it would be an AOW too, but the manufacturer has an ATF letter classifying it as a GCA Title I pistol. Of course, that doesn't mean the ATF won't change their mind at some point in the future.

Thanks, I overlooked that.

Depending on price, with the triple-projectile .38 ammo, that could be worth buying.

I didn't see a price on the preorder thingy.

RPB wrote:Depending on price, with the triple-projectile .38 ammo, that could be worth buying.

I dunno, it seems kind of gimmcky. I have yet to be convinced that any of the new "boutique" self defense rounds do anything better than a quality JHP from a reputable maker (besides putting large amounts of money in the pocket of their manufacturer, since it is not uncommon for them to cost $1/rd or more).

I also don't see what the Palm Pistol can do that a J-frame .38 or a pocket .380 can't accomplish, but I am not the target market (nor, I imagine, are most of the people on a gun board).

WildBill wrote:I am not missing that point. I am not a medical expert, but I think that there are other, less expensive and better alternatives that are already available for seniors or other shooters with weak hands or wrists. If this product fills a niche market and is a success, I have no problem. I would think that any S/A automatic or revolver would be able to do the job as well as this palm pistol.

Trying to get it listed as a medical device so that Medicare/Medicaid would subsidize the cost is a novel idea, but I don't think it will fly. If the inventor can prove that it also lowers cholesterol then maybe he will have a chance.

I know (well, I read a while back) that the medical device route failed, probably because of the not-lowering-cholesterol thing. Though, you could say it is a weight-loss device, since punching a hole in someone causes fluid to leak out, leading to (albeit temporary) weight loss. Unless one assumes room temperature, then there's permanent weight loss on the horizon.

WildBill, I didn't realize that you and TAM had taken into account the original intent. I thought it might be a feasible option for some, but upon further review (and y'alls further explanation), I think y'all are on the right track.

If this thing ever does make it to the market, it might just wind up being a curiosity and collector's item more than an actual-use firearm (or firepalm as the case may be).