Page 2 of 2
Re: Howard Leight Impact Sport vs. Impact Pro
Posted: Mon Jan 30, 2017 12:34 pm
by Pariah3j
Abraham wrote:I use my Impact model muffs for pistol shooting only and a different non-electronic muffs for rifle.
I've considered doing something like this, but I enjoy the ability of being able to hold a conversation w/ the electronic earmuffs, as I often go with either with my wife or a friend.
Anyone know what type of electronic earmuffs the military uses ? My assumption is they wouldn't use them if they didn't allow for a proper cheek weld - of course I'm sure they also cost alot more then civilian models.
Re: Howard Leight Impact Sport vs. Impact Pro
Posted: Mon Jan 30, 2017 12:45 pm
by Pariah3j
For anyone interested, came across this video while doing some research this morning :
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7IL8InVDHkY
Goes over several brands, and in particular one of the models (3M Peltor if I remember correctly) has some gel cup upgrades that supposedly is more comfortable and does better with glasses, etc - which is one of the things I know I read some users having trouble with.
Re: Howard Leight Impact Sport vs. Impact Pro
Posted: Mon Jan 30, 2017 1:18 pm
by jkurtz
Pariah3j wrote:For anyone interested, came across this video while doing some research this morning :
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7IL8InVDHkY
Goes over several brands, and in particular one of the models (3M Peltor if I remember correctly) has some gel cup upgrades that supposedly is more comfortable and does better with glasses, etc - which is one of the things I know I read some users having trouble with.
I use the MSA Sordins with gel cups. They are by far the most comfortable ear muffs I have used.
For the OP, I suggest looking to see if the Howard Leights have the ability to upgrade to gel cups.
Re: Howard Leight Impact Sport vs. Impact Pro
Posted: Mon Jan 30, 2017 4:35 pm
by Abraham
jkurtz,
I like your suggestion, but I first have to feel how comfortable the Pro model is.
It may be such that no gel cup upgrade is necessary.
I think the Pro model is a bargain compared to the very high end muff models on the market if it's what I hope it is...
Re: Howard Leight Impact Sport vs. Impact Pro
Posted: Mon Jan 30, 2017 4:53 pm
by puma guy
I have both the HL Impact Sport and The Impact Pro. I use passive foam ear plugs with both, especially when shooting indoors and the Pro affords better decibel reduction than the Sport. The Pro's are a little more comfortable, but the muff is so thick it interferes when I shoot a long arm, especially shotguns and traditional Monte Carlo rifle stocks. Wearing muffs for long periods becomes uncomfortable regardless of which version I use, but the Pro has a little thicker padding. Howard Leight no longer lists the Impact Pro on their website as far as I can find. They are still available on-line for 50-60 dollars. I suspect that;s because they're discontinued. I paid more than that.
When hearing protection began in earnest in the workplace our refinery offered myriad choices of types of hearing protection. Earmuffs were one of the most popular. We had the behind the head band and hardhat attachable versions, until operators who wore them for extended periods found out how sore an ear can become from doing that. (myself included) Eventually the most popular and the most comfortable and effective choice was the cylindrical E-A-R yellow foam plugs. I personally liked them better, also. The problem was they were single use. After the coated foam versions became available much later, they were the first choice of most every one.
Re: Howard Leight Impact Sport vs. Impact Pro
Posted: Tue Jan 31, 2017 11:13 am
by Abraham
puma guy,
Thanks for the review between the Impact or Pro H.L. muffs.
Most helpful.
Yes, from what I know the Pro model is a big old honker in size, but have you noticed any significant weight difference between the two?
Would you think a gel cup upgrade could be done and more importantly would greatly benefit comfort?
Thanks!
Re: Howard Leight Impact Sport vs. Impact Pro
Posted: Wed Feb 01, 2017 12:52 am
by puma guy
Abraham wrote:puma guy,
Thanks for the review between the Impact or Pro H.L. muffs.
Most helpful.
Yes, from what I know the Pro model is a big old honker in size, but have you noticed any significant weight difference between the two?
Would you think a gel cup upgrade could be done and more importantly would greatly benefit comfort?
Thanks!
I know the Pros probably weigh more, but not enough to notice. The gel cup would probably help. I haven't checked HL's website to see if they have an upgrade, I didn't see any obvious option. After wearing either pair for 4-5 hours I'm glad to get them both off my ears.