Page 1 of 2

Shooting onboard Nuclear Sub in UK

Posted: Fri Apr 08, 2011 1:01 pm
by sjfcontrol
How can it be? They don't have any guns over there?

http://www.guardian.co.uk/uk/2011/apr/0 ... njures-two" onclick="window.open(this.href);return false;

Re: Shooting onboard Nuclear Sub in UK

Posted: Fri Apr 08, 2011 1:04 pm
by Beiruty
Good thing, they did not use a Nuke! :rolll :rolll

Re: Shooting onboard Nuclear Sub in UK

Posted: Fri Apr 08, 2011 1:34 pm
by Barbi Q
sjfcontrol wrote:How can it be? They don't have any guns over there?
Civilian nuclear subs? :shock:

Re: Shooting onboard Nuclear Sub in UK

Posted: Fri Apr 08, 2011 7:06 pm
by sugar land dave
The sailor was involved in a changing of the guard duty thus he was armed. He killed an officer. Being in the military, there will be no civilian trial. It will all be handled in service and his life is basically over too.

Re: Shooting onboard Nuclear Sub in UK

Posted: Sat Apr 09, 2011 6:38 pm
by ScottDLS
sugar land dave wrote:The sailor was involved in a changing of the guard duty thus he was armed. He killed an officer. Being in the military, there will be no civilian trial. It will all be handled in service and his life is basically over too.
Are you sure? Do you know the procedures for military/civilian crown trials in the UK?

Re: Shooting onboard Nuclear Sub in UK

Posted: Sat Apr 09, 2011 8:46 pm
by sugar land dave
ScottDLS wrote:
sugar land dave wrote:The sailor was involved in a changing of the guard duty thus he was armed. He killed an officer. Being in the military, there will be no civilian trial. It will all be handled in service and his life is basically over too.
Are you sure? Do you know the procedures for military/civilian crown trials in the UK?
If you are challenging the contention that an officer murdered at a guard post at a military dock where a NATO member naval vessel is secured is a tribunal matter, I would be interested in your basis for disbelief that the military takes care of their own business.

Re: Shooting onboard Nuclear Sub in UK

Posted: Sat Apr 09, 2011 9:23 pm
by Pug
I rather imagine the old boy's career is over as well, but...

What this post actually reminded me of was the line from Sean Connery in 'Hunt for Red October' when he sayd:

"Most things in here don't react well to bullets." Yikes!

:fire

Re: Shooting onboard Nuclear Sub in UK

Posted: Sat Apr 09, 2011 9:35 pm
by sugar land dave
Pug wrote:I rather imagine the old boy's career is over as well, but...

What this post actually reminded me of was the line from Sean Connery in 'Hunt for Red October' when he sayd:

"Most things in here don't react well to bullets." Yikes!

:fire
Most likely they were at the upper or lower area of the gangplank. Inside the sub.... would not be good.

Re: Shooting onboard Nuclear Sub in UK

Posted: Sat Apr 09, 2011 11:05 pm
by philip964
Pug wrote:I rather imagine the old boy's career is over as well, but...

What this post actually reminded me of was the line from Sean Connery in 'Hunt for Red October' when he sayd:

"Most things in here don't react well to bullets." Yikes!

:fire
Jack Ryan then repeats the sentence after the "cook" is firing at him in amongst all the missile tubes, in a great impersonation of Sean's Edinburgh accent.

The crew was conducting a VIP tour and the quick thinking mayor of the town saved the day by pinning the gunman to the wall where he was able to grab the gunman's rifle from him.

This probably illustrates the kind of rare tight situation where a handgun is preferable to a rifle.

Re: Shooting onboard Nuclear Sub in UK

Posted: Sun Apr 10, 2011 10:20 am
by ScottDLS
sugar land dave wrote:
ScottDLS wrote:
sugar land dave wrote:The sailor was involved in a changing of the guard duty thus he was armed. He killed an officer. Being in the military, there will be no civilian trial. It will all be handled in service and his life is basically over too.
Are you sure? Do you know the procedures for military/civilian crown trials in the UK?
If you are challenging the contention that an officer murdered at a guard post at a military dock where a NATO member naval vessel is secured is a tribunal matter, I would be interested in your basis for disbelief that the military takes care of their own business.
Hasan could get tried in Texas state court for capital murder, though the Army chose to charge him under UCMJ. Do you KNOW that the UK doesn't have a similar possibility?

Re: Shooting onboard Nuclear Sub in UK

Posted: Sun Apr 10, 2011 11:38 am
by b322da
sjfcontrol wrote:How can it be? They don't have any guns over there?
They do on warships.

Elmo

Re: Shooting onboard Nuclear Sub in UK

Posted: Sun Apr 10, 2011 12:31 pm
by sugar land dave
ScottDLS wrote:
sugar land dave wrote:
ScottDLS wrote:
sugar land dave wrote:The sailor was involved in a changing of the guard duty thus he was armed. He killed an officer. Being in the military, there will be no civilian trial. It will all be handled in service and his life is basically over too.
Are you sure? Do you know the procedures for military/civilian crown trials in the UK?
If you are challenging the contention that an officer murdered at a guard post at a military dock where a NATO member naval vessel is secured is a tribunal matter, I would be interested in your basis for disbelief that the military takes care of their own business.
Hasan could get tried in Texas state court for capital murder, though the Army chose to charge him under UCMJ. Do you KNOW that the UK doesn't have a similar possibility?
Again, is there a reason you feel the need to challenge military authority over people in their charge? I don't come here to argue, but to learn. Regarding matters such as this, perhaps I already know. Nevertheless, I do not feel the need to justify such.

It is a tragedy. It will be handled. I personally couldn't care less who takes care of the justice side of the incident, and I have no interest in a debate.

Re: Shooting onboard Nuclear Sub in UK

Posted: Sun Apr 10, 2011 12:37 pm
by sugar land dave
philip964 wrote:
Pug wrote:I rather imagine the old boy's career is over as well, but...

What this post actually reminded me of was the line from Sean Connery in 'Hunt for Red October' when he sayd:

"Most things in here don't react well to bullets." Yikes!

:fire
Jack Ryan then repeats the sentence after the "cook" is firing at him in amongst all the missile tubes, in a great impersonation of Sean's Edinburgh accent.

The crew was conducting a VIP tour and the quick thinking mayor of the town saved the day by pinning the gunman to the wall where he was able to grab the gunman's rifle from him.

This probably illustrates the kind of rare tight situation where a handgun is preferable to a rifle.
The story today is somewhat different from what was initially reported. It now sounds as if this incident took place inside the sub. Yikes indeed!

Re: Shooting onboard Nuclear Sub in UK

Posted: Sun Apr 10, 2011 12:47 pm
by b322da
sugar land dave wrote: The story today is somewhat different from what was initially reported. It now sounds as if this incident took place inside the sub. Yikes indeed!
Indeed, Dave, I suspect the most troubling aspect of this incident may have to do with the UK's program for predetermining the mental stability of candidates for becoming a member of the crew of nuclear subs. Similarly, it may be the most likely source of embarrassment for the Royal Navy. That is, this may be for the UK what the Fort Hood shooting incident was for us.

Elmo

PS Some day I hope to be able to restrain my mouth and my fingers on the keyboard until a news story plays itself out more.

Re: Shooting onboard Nuclear Sub in UK

Posted: Sun Apr 10, 2011 1:11 pm
by sugar land dave
b322da wrote:That is, this may be for the UK what the Fort Hood shooting incident was for us.
To use an old colloquialism, "Heads will roll."