Toons wrote:Responding to this scene as a CHL'r would be a nightmare. Think of it, you are sitting with your family in a booth, other families & kids around you. These three charge in guns a waving, what are your choices? Start shooting and end up drawing fire to your table with your family around you? Then what if you choose to do nothing, they demand you lay on the floor and they then discover your gun as they search for wallets. A quick shot to your head and you are done.
Maybe you jump from the booth and try to make it to a vacant part of the restaurant where you can take a position and open fire? I don't have an answer, but I do know this scene is why I carry a 13 round mag, at least I can start shooting and hope I either hit all three or they bolt for the door in the hail of lead. I would love to hear an experts opinion on how to react in this situation.
This is a good analysis. I think any honest experts will tell you that every situation is too dynamic to provide any guidance as to a proper response. (Of course, the official Houston Police Dept. advice would be that you shouldn't resist and simply take your changes. That's easy to say when you sitting on your fat butt in your safe office wearing your gold badge and multiple stars while your politician puppeteer is pulling your strings. /rant)
As JALLEN pointed out, in this situation the murderers came in firing so the script is pretty well written. It is rare that I can or will give a firm statement as to how I would react but with this fact pattern, these guys get shot as quickly as I can respond. I shoot a lot so I am confident in my skill at arms and I carry a gun I can shoot very accurately (5" 1911), rather than one that fits well in the pocket. I would select my line of fire to the extent time and physical layout of the room allow, but time is of the essence. As noted in the photo, they were coming through the door single file and if the first guy was firing, then I rather like the idea of firing into a bullet funnel (doorway). Obviously this may not have been possible for various reasons, but the only thing worse than fighting three guys in front of you is fighting three guys scattered all around. In all likelihood, if you drop one thug (cleaned up from COP parlance) the others will run like the gutless cowards they really are, but they may well do so shooting wildly.
{soapbox} If you are going to carry a gun, then carry a gun and not a toy or handgun-light! Learn not only how to shoot that gun, but how to fight with your gun. Those are two very different skills. {/soapbox}
I pray the Lord will let me live out my remaining days never again having to touch my gun in fear, but if I must, then make me fast and accurate so that others may live. (I've said that prayer long before Mel Gibson's The Patriot movie.)
Chas.