First, the Supertuck, for my Walther PPKS.
The, the MTAC, for my Springfield XD subcompact 40:
Both are left-handed. One thing I noticed is that I need bigger pants, since mine are not loose at all and not meant for carrying. Somehow, they've shrunk over the years.
As to the holsters, both fit the guns extremely well. The MTAC, in horsehide natural, is nicely made and finished. The Supertuck is in black cowhide, and a little less fancy-looking, but well done. Both fit well with a t-shirt and not-so-loose pants.
I am wearing the Supertuck around the house now with the Walther, to break it in, and will do the same with the MTAC later this week. I am awaiting my CHL from Texas anyway (should be any day) so not carrying at the moment.