Receive two licenses? I received my CHL about 2 weeks ago and just today I received another license in the mail. Kind of odd, just wondering if this has happened to anyone else.
I think it's a non-issue. If they were two different licenses (different numbers, different issue date, etc) then you'd need to get it worked out. As it is, he's just got a duplicate license. There's nothing wrong with that by any measure I can determine.
Trying to fix it is going to lead to a situation where there is a huge potential for misunderstandings, most of which would not work out in RedRaider's favor...
Nope, you are not supposed to have 2 licenses. I'd cut up one and send it back. (I would not worry about certifying it, etc.)
If you get a NSA (non-semit automatic) license and later upgrade to a SA, you HAVE to send the old NSA license back. Failure to do so could cost you a 30 day suspension.
OTOH, you might just destroy the extra and forget about it.